IUFRO Spotlight #4

Forests: The Carbon Conundrum

PDF for download

By Robert Jandl, Deputy Coordinator of IUFRO Division 8
(BFW, Austria)

In the coming decades, forests will play a major role in our planet's carbon cycle and in our efforts to manage the amount of carbon in the atmosphere.

Getting a better understanding of whether that role might be good (a sink, absorbing carbon) or bad (a source, adding carbon to the atmosphere), motivated a study by Yude Pan and colleagues, recently published in Science Express.

The study identifies global forests as the major terrestrial carbon sink (as opposed to grasslands, peatlands or agricultural lands). It is the first such study to base conclusions on forest inventory and land cover data instead of simulation results.

Using data from around the world, the Pan study shows the distribution of carbon sources and sinks, the importance of temperate and boreal forests as sustained sinks and the enormous fluxes (sources and sinks) contributed by tropical forests.

But overall, the study shows the forests' role, at least for now, is positive. They are carbon sinks.

As sinks, they currently absorb about 27% of the 8 billion tons of fossil fuel emissions we emit yearly – giving us an arboreal discount on emissions. Factor in oceans and other terrestrial ecosystems and the total absorption rate goes up to over 50%. Without these natural sinks, the rate of CO2 increase in the atmosphere would be substantially higher.

But part of the reason for this forest sink rests with some one-time occurrences: recovery of European temperate and boreal forest following intensive land use; transformation of large tracts of Eastern European and Russian agricultural land that were abandoned and have since reverted to forest and, in China, some 40 million ha of afforestation – land that had been used for other purposes or was just barren and has now been turned back into forest. It would be difficult to find that kind of spare land again, so that situation is not likely to reoccur. That will make it more difficult to maintain the current sink into the future.

And, should climate change advance too far and forests and other terrestrial ecosystems transform from carbon sinks to carbon sources and begin pumping vast quantities of carbon into the atmosphere, human efforts to mitigate climate change could be overwhelmed.

Having and sharing solid forest inventory data and continuing robust forest monitoring, will help us understand the forests' role in the carbon cycle. That's important, because there seem to be two vastly different possible responses.

On the optimistic side is a scenario where, in a warmer world, trees will grow faster, enjoy a longer growing season, flourish in areas where they had never before grown, take in more carbon and increase the carbon sink.

The more pessimistic view is that warmer temperatures will mean more forest fires, more insect depredation, more dead and dying trees, more peatland decomposition, thawing permafrost and the transformation of terrestrial ecosystems into carbon sources.

We can't say with any certainty which path the forests will follow. But we know that the global track record on carbon emissions isn't great. From 2000-2009 carbon in the atmosphere rose by 4.1 billion tons a year. And in 2010, global carbon emissions increased by 5.9%, the highest annual increase on record. We seem to be heading in the wrong direction at an accelerating pace.

We must do what we can to change or, at the least, mitigate that trend. Forests, and our knowledge of their response to climate change, are critical to accomplishing that.

The full study, A Large and Persistent Carbon Sink in the World's Forests, can be found at:


IUFRO Spotlight is an initiative of the International Union of Forest Research Organizations. Its aim is to introduce, in a timely fashion, significant findings in forest research from IUFRO member organizations and/or involving IUFRO officeholders to a worldwide network of decision makers, policy makers and researchers.

IUFRO will encapsulate, and distribute in plain language, brief, topical and policy-relevant highlights of those findings, along with information on where/how to access the full documents. The IUFRO Spotlight findings will be distributed in a periodic series of emails as well as blog postings.

The findings reported here are submitted by IUFRO Member Organizations. IUFRO is pleased to highlight and circulate these findings to a broad audience but, in doing so, acts only as a conduit. The quality and accuracy of the reports are the responsibility of the member organization and the authors.

Suggestions for reports and findings that could be promoted through IUFRO Spotlight are encouraged. Please send them to: wolfrum(at)iufro.org. To be considered, reports should be fresh, have policy implications and be applicable to more than one country.


Robert Jandl: +43-1-87838 ext. 1120 or robert.jandl(at)bfw.gv.at
Gerda Wolfrum: +43 1 877 0151 17 or wolfrum(at)iufro.org


Study: A Large and Persistent Carbon Sink in the World's Forests: http://www.globalcarbonproject.org/products/publications.htm

IUFRO Division 8.00.00 – Forest Environment: http://www.iufro.org/science/divisions/division-8/80000/


Photo Credits

Photo 1: Rain forest in Costa Rica. Photo by Judith Stöger-Goiser, IUFRO Headquarters
Photo 2: Delegates of the 4th International Poplar Symposium in China inspecting a Populus deltoides propagation nursery in Jiangsu Province. Photo by Brian Stanton, Coordinator of IUFRO Working Party 2.08.04


The International Union of Forest Research Organizations (IUFRO) is the only worldwide organization devoted to forest research and related sciences. Its members are research institutions, universities, and individual scientists as well as decision-making authorities and other stakeholders with a focus on forests and trees.
Visit: http://www.iufro.org/


PDF for download


View all IUFRO Spotlights at http://www.iufro.org/media/iufro-spotlights/ 


IUFRO Spotlight #4, published in January 2012
by IUFRO Headquarters, Vienna, Austria.
Available for download at:
Contact the editor at office(at)iufro.org or visit http://www.iufro.org/

Imprint: http://www.iufro.org/legal/#c18944